
Ambiguous Loss and the “Long Goodbye” Guilt
I am not a therapist, counselor, or psychologist. I’m sharing what I’ve witnessed over about 30 years as an activity director and adult day program director, sitting with families going through this. If grief is overwhelming you, please reach out to a counselor, your doctor, a caregiver support group, or the Alzheimer’s Association’s 24/7 Helpline at 1-800-272-3900.
Some of the most important conversations I had as a program director didn’t happen in my office, they happened in the parking lot. A daughter sitting in her car after dropping off her mom, not quite ready to drive. A husband lingering by the door with his keys in his hand. When I’d stop to say hello, it would all come out.
That kind of grief has a name..
What Is Ambiguous Loss?
The term “ambiguous loss” was developed by Dr. Pauline Boss, a family therapist and researcher. One form of it describes exactly what dementia families live with: the person is physically present but psychologically or cognitively changing, sometimes beyond recognition. They’re here and not here at the same time.
Ordinary grief, as painful as it is, has an ending to point to. There’s a funeral, people bring casseroles, the world acknowledges the loss. With dementia, the loss happens gradually, like a dandelion losing its seeds in the breeze, in slow motion The first time she forgets your name. The day he can’t find his way home. The visit where she thinks you’re her sister or someone competing for her husband. Each one is a little death, a turmoil for you and nobody brings a casserole.
The Guilt Nobody Talks About
Family caregivers have told me things in quiet moments they’d never say out loud anywhere else. I want you to know these feelings are common, from one human to another, I don’t think it makes you a bad person. It’s just natural emotions I found:
- Relief guilt. Feeling relieved when you leave the visit, drop them off or when someone else takes over care.
- Wishing it were over. Wanting the suffering to end, theirs and yours, and then feeling horrified at yourself.
- Anger. At the disease, at siblings who don’t help, sometimes at the person themselves.
- Grieving “too early.” Feeling like you’re not allowed to mourn someone who’s still alive.
- Missing who they were while loving who they are now, and feeling like those two things are a betrayal of each other.
Holding Two Truths at Once
One idea that has helped many families I’ve known is learning to hold “both/and” instead of “either/or.” She’s still my mother, and she’s not the mother I had. I love him, and I’m exhausted. I’m grateful for this visit, and it breaks my heart. Both are true. You don’t have to choose.
Dr. Boss writes about this kind of thinking, and in my experience, it gives people permission to stop trying to resolve something that can’t be resolved. As someone who isn’t credentialed to provide counseling, I did share that I found their thoughts and emotions typical after listening, would tell them their feelings were valid and provide what tips I could for at home and provide referrals to our caregiver support group and other resources.
For Life Enrichment Staff: Holding Space for Families
Activity and life enrichment staff are often closer to families than we realize. They plan the holiday parties, the family nights, the birthday celebrations. Those events can be joyful, and they can also be gut punches. The bustling home that once welcomed thirty loved ones for Thanksgiving now quietly gathers around a simple kitchen table. Here are things I learned to do intentionally:
- Offer a quiet space. Have a room or corner where a family member can step away for a few minutes without explanation.
- Give families a role. Pouring punch, reading a poem, helping lead a song. Having something to do can soften the sting.
- Don’t say “at least.” “At least she’s comfortable.” “At least she still knows you.” These are well meant, but they can shut grief down. Just listen. Say, “I understand.”
- Check in on the regulars. The husband who comes every day is grieving every day. A cup of coffee and two minutes of attention matter.
- Celebrate who the person was. Life story boards, favorite songs, and memory displays honor the whole person and remind families that staff see them too.
Small Things That Help Families
None of these fix it. But families have told me these are some of the things they did that helped:
- Writing letters to the person as they were, even if they’ll never be read.
- Keeping a small journal of good moments, so the hard ones don’t erase them.
- Finding a caregiver support group where people “get it” without explanation.
- Giving yourself permission to visit less sometimes, without guilt.
- Talking with a counselor who understands dementia and grief.
You’re Not Alone
If you’re living the long goodbye, please hear this from someone who has walked beside a lot of families: what you’re feeling is real grief. You’re allowed to mourn. You’re allowed to laugh at a visit and cry in the car afterward. Both are love.
