Meeting Them Where They Are: The Ethics and Peace of Embracing Fiblets

Every afternoon around three, she’d get her purse and head for the door. “I have to get home. My kids will be getting off the bus.” Her youngest son graduated college 25 years earlier.

When confronted with the truth, she collapsed into a chair, confused, as if she were being lied to. Because in her reality, she was. And by the next afternoon, the cycle started all over again.

That’s the heart of why many dementia caregivers, and many professionals, have moved away from correcting and toward something that made more sense.

How We Used to Do It

For a long time, the standard approach was “reality orientation.” Remind people of the date, the place, the facts. Correct mistakes. Keep them grounded. The intention was good. But for people in the middle and later stages of dementia, in my experience, it often just caused distress over and over, without the person being able to hold onto the adjustment.

Approaches like Naomi Feil’s validation method shifted the focus. Instead of insisting on our reality, we step into theirs, and respond to the feeling underneath the words.

What’s a Therapeutic Fiblet?

A “therapeutic fiblet” is a small, kind untruth, or a calm redirection, used to spare a person with dementia unnecessary pain or fear. It’s not about deceiving them for our convenience. It’s about meeting them where they are.

“Your mother’s fine. Let’s have some tea while we wait” is a fiblet. It answers the worry without forcing her to grieve all over again.

It’s a Spectrum, Not a License

Here’s how I’ve always thought about it, from soothing to last resort:

  1. Respond to the feeling. “You sound worried about your mom. Tell me about her.” Often, just being heard is enough.
  2. Redirect. “Before you go, could you help me with these napkins?” Shift attention to something else.
  3. Answer without confirming or denying. “She loved you so much.” True, kind, and doesn’t break their heart.
  4. Gentle fiblet. “She called and said she’s running late.” Used when the first three haven’t worked and the truth would only cause suffering.

Most of the time, you won’t need step four. But when you do, it’s okay.

Why It Can Feel So Wrong

Most of us were raised to believe lying is wrong, period. And lying to a loved one? That can feel like a betrayal of everything you were taught. Families have told me it felt like they were “giving up” on their person, or treating them like a child.

I understand that. But here’s how I see it: honesty exists to serve trust and love. When the truth only causes pain the person can’t process or remember, insisting on it isn’t serving them. It’s serving our own discomfort. Choosing kindness is not a betrayal. It’s a different way of honoring them.

When Not to Use Fiblets

  • When the person is in an earlier stage and can process and remember the truth.
  • When it’s about something they genuinely need to know for their safety or care decisions.
  • When it’s mainly about making our lives easier rather than reducing their distress.
  • When a simpler approach (listening, redirecting) would work just as well.

For Care Teams: Consistency Matters

If one staff member says “Your husband is at work” and another says “Your husband passed away,” the person ends up confused. In care settings, talk as a team (and with families) about how you’ll respond to common questions. Write it in the care plan. Consistency is a gift to the person.

Letting Go of the Guilt

If you’ve started joining your loved one’s reality and feel guilty about it, I want to tell you what I told so many families: you’re not lying to hurt them. You’re choosing not to hurt them. That’s love, just in a form nobody prepared you for.

A quick note: I’m not a psychologist, therapist, or medical professional. What I’m sharing comes from about 30 years in senior care, as an activity director and adult day program director. Every person and situation is different, so please talk with your loved one’s care team about what’s right for them.